Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Open letter to Winnipeg City Council

I originally sent this letter to Councilor Gord Steeves who was quoted in several news articles in the past week. 

Winnipeg is considering lifting the shape specific dog ban that has been in place since 1996. Mr. Steeves acknowledged receiving my letter without further comment. I truly hope all the councilors do the right thing.

Dear Mayor of Winnipeg and Winnipeg City Council;
I am writing to you regarding news articles I've read in the past couple days concerning the possibility of lifting the dog ban in Winnipeg.

First, I would like to say I want to give you the benefit of the doubt that you have been exposed to some facts. 
There is plenty of information debunking the age old myths surrounding support for breed bans. I am not going to waste my time or yours going into a long winded tirade.
The facts support that;
1. "pitbulls" do not exist. It is a slang term for a generic shape of dog. 
2. The purebreds American Staffordshire Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier and American Pit Bull Terrier are extremely rare in Canada. There are breed registry numbers to support this. There are less than 1000 dogs all three breeds combined in Ontario.
3. Breed bans do nothing to prevent dog attacks. This has been proven countless times which has resulted in repealing of breed bans in many countries, cities and jurisdictions globally.
Propaganda is the only support for breed bans. Dangerous dogs exist in all breeds and cross breeds of dogs. It is not a breed or dog issue it is an owner issue.
Calgary has had much success for 20+ years with its Responsible Pet Ownership bylaw. It targets irresponsible owners, has a 95% plus compliance of dog licensing and state of the art facility that hosts the Pound, Humane Society and Animal Control working simultaneously to protect the community. They reward responsible pet ownership and deal with those who are not. The program is revenue neutral and the best part is the citizens of Calgary are onside and support the bylaw because it allows pet owners and non pet owners to live peacefully. 
We have been living a nightmare of the dog ban here in Ontario for the past 6 yrs. Family pets have been taken from good homes based on how their dog looks. Innocent people have been stripped of their family pet and life savings trying to save their dog's life. The heartache is vast and the results are grim.
People continue to be bitten and sometimes severely injured by all breeds of dogs. Breed bans have nothing to do with behavior and everything to do with how a dog looks. Breed bans are a draconian, barbaric legislation that target innocent people and innocent dogs. Real criminals don't care one bit about whether they are breaking the law much less what breed they own. 
Are there dangerous dogs and irresponsible owners? Yes of course there are and there are ways to deal with owners who pose a threat to the community. Trying to define a cross bred dog or target 3 very rare breeds does nothing to deal with that threat. 95% of all dog bites occur at home with the family pet or an adjacent property. Most bites happen because of lack of training and socialization of the family pet.
Encouraging people to train/contain and socialize their dog goes a long way. Providing an environment that encourages people to be responsible works wonders.
It is possible you just haven't been exposed to the facts but somehow I doubt that. The facts are as easy to find as the myths. Do the right thing. Using common sense and fair and equal treatment under the law gets you many more brownie points as a politician than following the propaganda. Do the right thing for Winnipeg and invite Bill Bruce from Calgary to speak to your council. He speaks globally about the Calgary model and how to implement it in your city. 
Thanks for your consideration,


  1. I Agree with this letter to the mayor, Ive owned a Stafford Shire bull terrier before moving to Winnipeg and it is a great dog and all it wants to do is please the owner. In England this dog is called the nanny dog because how great this animal is with kids. Bad people turn this dog bad.
    This dog is not a Wild Cat at a zoo, it wont just turn on humans, you have to treat this animal terrible to do that.

    Ryan( Winnipeg Resident)

  2. The Staffordshire Bull Terrier (informally: Staffie, Stafford, Staffross, Staffy or Staff) is a medium-sized, short-coated, old-time breed of dog, originally bred for dog fighting after bull baiting became illegal. With dogfighting then also being made illegal, the breed evolved into one with a temperament suitable for a pet and companion, gaining respectability and becoming a dog worthy to show. It was accepted by The Kennel Club of the United Kingdom as the Staffordshire bull terrier in 1935. [1] The breed that is currently found in the United States has no fighting history since its migration over the Atlantic and is a direct descendant of the show dogs of the United Kingdom. It is an English breed of dog related to the bull terrier and similar in appearance to the much larger American Staffordshire terrier and American pit bull terrier. The breed is the 5th most popular dog in the UK (its place of origin), and it is the only breed to have the words 'totally reliable' in its breed standard. Furthermore, the Staffordshire Bull Terrier is one of only two breeds from over 190 recognized by the UK Kennel Club to have a mention of the breed's suitability with children